Try our mobile site, m.phish.net!

Phish.net: a Project of the Mockingbird Foundation




Back to Forum Back to Forum Oldest First Oldest First Newest First Newest First

Bittersweet Motel

IenjoyMyself Permalink
IenjoyMyself page got a new shirt!!!
Score: 0

sharininthegroove09 Permalink
sharininthegroove09 Woah they have the entire thing on Google? I mean I have my own DVD of it but you would think there would be copyright issues of some kind. Pretty fun film though.
Score: 1

icculus1985 Permalink
icculus1985 @sharininthegroove09 said:
Woah they have the entire thing on Google? I mean I have my own DVD of it but you would think there would be copyright issues of some kind. Pretty fun film though.
Yeah, I was surprised about this too when I saw that it was one there a couple months ago.
Score: 0

TheDeerman Permalink
TheDeerman Dudes, this documentary is out to get the band and make 'em look bad. Especially Trey. To the casual music fan, this film is absolutely designed to make Phish look incredibly egotistical with a fan base that doesn't appreciate quality music. I can't say I'm a fan. Watch it, though.
Score: 0

IenjoyMyself Permalink
IenjoyMyself @TheDeerman said:
Dudes, this documentary is out to get the band and make 'em look bad. Especially Trey. To the casual music fan, this film is absolutely designed to make Phish look incredibly egotistical with a fan base that doesn't appreciate quality music. I can't say I'm a fan. Watch it, though.
agree and disagree. The Documentary doesn't make the band look great, and definitely depicts the fans poorly too. BUT, i don't think that Todd Phillips had that intent. I believe it was Phish's idea to film the documentary and they purposefully brought in someone who wasn't a phan so it would have some objectivity. They wanted to explain phish to people who had never heard of em. I don't know that there is any part that makes them look egotistical....confident sure, but not cocky. I mean Trey sits there and reads bad reviews about themselves while laughing about it. There really is limited interaction with any of the other members (which is dissapointing), but there are some humorous parts as well as some decent musical clips. Cant believe dude was touring with the boys in 97 and couldn't dig up some better musical clips.

Anyways, definitely some shitty messages put out because of the documentary but for fans its actually laughable.
Score: 1

icculus1985 Permalink
icculus1985 @IenjoyMyself said:
@TheDeerman said:
Dudes, this documentary is out to get the band and make 'em look bad. Especially Trey. To the casual music fan, this film is absolutely designed to make Phish look incredibly egotistical with a fan base that doesn't appreciate quality music. I can't say I'm a fan. Watch it, though.
agree and disagree. The Documentary doesn't make the band look great, and definitely depicts the fans poorly too. BUT, i don't think that Todd Phillips had that intent. I believe it was Phish's idea to film the documentary and they purposefully brought in someone who wasn't a phan so it would have some objectivity. They wanted to explain phish to people who had never heard of em. I don't know that there is any part that makes them look egotistical....confident sure, but not cocky. I mean Trey sits there and reads bad reviews about themselves while laughing about it. There really is limited interaction with any of the other members (which is dissapointing), but there are some humorous parts as well as some decent musical clips. Cant believe dude was touring with the boys in 97 and couldn't dig up some better musical clips.

Anyways, definitely some shitty messages put out because of the documentary but for fans its actually laughable.
I always thought that it was pretty bogus when they were cutting everybody's heads off in the pictures. I would be pretty excited to be able to get a picture with them. And then get the pictures developed and no one has a head. Thank god for digital cameras. Those sneaky bastards won't trick me when the day arrives. ;)
Score: 0

IenjoyMyself Permalink
IenjoyMyself Agreed...hilarious..but cruel
Score: 0

sharininthegroove09 Permalink
sharininthegroove09 Yeah I disagree. Sure, it could have absolutely been better, but for what it is, it is a pretty cool documentary. I mean the director did put things in the wrong order, and more interviews with the other band members could have been better, and better musical highlights could have been used, but it was made by a dude who is not really a fan, so look at it that way.

And think of all the footage that exists that wasn't in the film, maybe that will surface someday too. :fingers crossed:
Score: 0

TheDeerman Permalink
TheDeerman @sharininthegroove09 said:

And think of all the footage that exists that wasn't in the film, maybe that will surface someday too. :fingers crossed:
Hope you're right. I just feel like (1) taking shots before going onstage (2) Trey negotiating with the store clerk for the guns (3) The Dave fans in the tent (4) the drug dealers, and (5) the naked photo shoot bring way too much of a negative vibe for the band that does not overcome the funny parts to the non-phan. I still enjoyed it, but I wouldn't recommend this to someone trying to convert a noob. Just my $.02
Score: 0

forbin1 Permalink
forbin1 Some of the stuff was enjoyable...I always love seeing concert footage and some behind the scenes stuff...what about when that chick was stalking Trey backstage at the Great Went...and he was like "I have no idea who you are"..funny stuff...
Score: 0

IenjoyMyself Permalink
IenjoyMyself what drug dealers?

Trey bartering at the weapon store was comical, and how does the naked photo shoot bring negative vibes?
Score: 0

TheDeerman Permalink
TheDeerman @IenjoyMyself said:
what drug dealers?

Trey bartering at the weapon store was comical, and how does the naked photo shoot bring negative vibes?

You gotta look at this from the perspective of someone who doesn't know the scene at all. Of course it's funny to us, but to anyone who doesn't know who Trey is, he looks like an asshole. There's a guy who they interview that sells weed to stay on tour. The way they show the fans makes us look like we're all hippies/wookies/bros. Maybe that's the prominent image put out there, but that is definitely not the "average" phan.

Though I do have to admit that I didn't know the scene in '97. Maybe that's how it was? Still, I would guess not.
Score: 0

Sativar Permalink
Sativar This video was recently removed from Google video. I tried to watch it (again) a few weeks ago, and the video page stated that the video was marked as private. Now it doesn't show up on Google video search at all.

I signed up for a free trial of NetFlix to stream it, only to learn that it is only available on their (antiquated) "DVD by mail" service. Blah!

Let the rabbits wear glasses!
Score: 0

aSTRANGEdesign Permalink
aSTRANGEdesign @TheDeerman said:
(3) The Dave fans in the tent
that whole bit about VW's and girls with hairy armpits was just weird
Score: 0

EducateFright Permalink
EducateFright The band deliberately hired a complete outsider to make the film, thus it turned out the way it did. When it came out, there was nothing like it. At the time, it was such a rush and so intensely fascinating to see backstage footage of the band, to see them practicing, the candid interviews, their reactions to negative press, all that. (Up until then, the actual band members had always seemed to mysterious to me.) The stuff that casts the band and the fans in a rather negative light was all part of what was going on then. It's honest.
Score: 0

kipmat Permalink
kipmat blonde nitrous girl.

"Love... [huff] ...love will keep us together... [huff] ..."
Score: 0

EducateFright Permalink
EducateFright This is the good shit.



Score: 0

BlackPeter Permalink
BlackPeter I can tell you that in the part of the film when they were at a show and the camera crew was asking a fan, who was clearly a space shot, a question on why he listens to Phish and the kid answered with something like what a space shot would say, then the camera guy said that he didn't get it, and the kid kept going on with his space shot answer, the camera dude was clearly f***ing with him. So I don't know how much the filmmakers knew about Phish or not but that little part of the film made it seem like they knew what was going on with Phish and their fans. But I don't know just my two cents.
Score: 0

kipmat Permalink
kipmat @EducateFright said:
This is the good shit.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xjloX_EvYiI
No argument with this, or with your earlier post. I was just naming one of the most memorable parts of the movie (for me). Besides letting us get to know the band, I think "Bittersweet Motel" does a fine job of illustrating some of the different attributes vs. preconceptions of Phish fans. There are likely more than a few guys who go see Phish because they believe that girls like the blonde nitrous huffer will be there.
Score: 0

joyjoy Permalink
Good thread. I'm surprised how many vets hate on this film. I don't think it portrays fans negatively, just in the colorful light an outsider would see. (They even found a guy who said you don't need drugs to enjoy Phish! How many of those were on tour in '97?!) Trey has some absolutely priceless quotes in it and yes, the band come off as dicks sometimes, but I doubt that's inaccurate. Too bad there isn't more music, but it's great to be able to see some of the scene @ that moment in time.

The streaming versions ARE copyright infringements and keep getting taken down. I finally caved and spent 5$ on the DVD.. now I"ll probably never want to watch it again.
Score: 2

Onlymike Permalink
Onlymike Nobody mentioned Trey calling Brad a tool? That was it for me, honestly. I took a long break from Phish after that. No kidding.
Score: 0

BlackPeter Permalink
BlackPeter I think Trey summed up how we all feel at a show in this clip



Score: 0

splitopenandmelted Permalink
splitopenandmelted You guys.
The boys were trolling.
...Weren't they?? //gets nervous, questions evertything\\

(But seriously. My brother met Trey at an Indian's game, Trey saw how crazy excited/nervous my brudda was and so he initiated the hug, smiled and walked away. Can you imagine someone asking for a picture with Page pre-digital and Page allowing them to cut his head off? I love the movie because it's hysterically divergent from my view of the boys, with some truths and untruths I'm sure, but they are showmakers and love fugggin with the fans, so relax, take it easy. in the end, they're human. And funny. And sometimes douchers, like all of us)
Score: 2

BlackPeter Permalink
BlackPeter @Onlymike said:
Nobody mentioned Trey calling Brad a tool? That was it for me, honestly. I took a long break from Phish after that. No kidding.
I don't know if you are being sarcastic or not but Trey wasn't being an asshole he was just f***ing with Brad. In the clip before that scene Trey is in his hotel room and is asked by the cameraman if he had heard what someone said about a song they played the night before, Trey said no and the cameraman told him the person said the song was ruined or botched because they missed a change. Trey replied with that he could give a f*** if they missed a change and that he thought the whole night was quote "rockin'" The person who made that comment was Brad Sands. So that's why the next day Trey, half-jokingly, said kiss my ass you fckin tool and threw a beer can at him. He was pissed that Brad would care that they missed a change. It was not meant to be cruel, friends f*** with friends all the time, doesn't mean it doesn't happen in Phish.
Score: 1

BlackPeter Permalink
BlackPeter Unofficial Trailer



Score: 0

RoverPhish Permalink
some of the comments in this thread have left me scratching my head. Maybe the footage in Bittersweet doesnt translate as well now as it did when it came out?
Score: 0

JayDubya Permalink
JayDubya My favorite part of the whole movie is when Trey says "we're having the best tour ever and no one knows anything about it" -> DWD Jam.
Score: 3

GhostlikeSwayze Permalink
GhostlikeSwayze I'll be the first one to mention that that link says private video. I've seen Bittersweet Motel several times, and was trying to show it to a new phan just a couple days ago but it is nowhere to be found online. At least by someone with low internet download savviness
Score: 0

Capricornio Permalink
Capricornio I saw it when it was in theaters(extremely limited run) and I bought the DVD as soon as it came out. I really like this movie. I like it precisely because it doesn't "stroke" Phish off. It seems pretty unbiased to me(which is something you don't often get outside or within this community). As far as the light in which it shows fans, be honest, for every awesome person I've seen/met at a Phish show, I've met a total waste of space who was there just for the party. All the people they interviewed were real people who were really at a Phish show. Its not like they got some ringer to act like a waste-oid or a bro.

@TheDeerman said:
(2) Trey negotiating with the store clerk for the guns ... bring way too much of a negative vibe for the band that does not overcome the funny parts to the non-phan.
Bar none, my favorite scene in the whole movie.
Score: 1

Thunder Permalink
Thunder I love how they cut from Roses are Free rehearsal to show on that change! Saw this for the first time in a theatre in Peterborough, ON. Canada (actually promoted it/brought it in).

Also love during the NYE stuff when they show a clip of a group of peeps from St. Stephen NB Canada ... don't know em, but it's pretty handy to where I grew up ... very cool!

And how does anyone not love watching Trey slay the Went Simple.
Score: 1

Dollop_of_Murk Permalink
Dollop_of_Murk My brother was driving us to a theater in downtown Portland to see Bittersweet Motel when a woman dressed in black ran out of a bookstore into the rain at night, across several busy lanes of traffic, and in front of my brother's car. I watched her bounce off the hood.

Within a week of that, I read a review in a local alternative paper that attacked the film unfairly, making jokes in poor taste without actually offering a valid critique. The review commented about Phish fans being predominantly white, but the wording was borderline racist. When I saw the film a few weeks later, the comment made perfect sense after seeing the whole naked-on-the-runway scene (although the review was still in bad taste and without merit).

Anyway, my brother got a ticket and we missed the show, but at least the woman was ok and took a cab home. Funny thing is, I work for that bookstore now, and I can occasionally afford a new shirt for the girls in the front row/aisle/bumper.
Score: 1

buffalo_voice Permalink
buffalo_voice I think it was made in the tried and true documentary style that tries to show the whole enchilada, good and bad, in as objective of a way as possible. And I bet the band wanted it to be that way.

The GD Movie that Jerry himself directed and edited left in the scenes with the concession stand vendor who doesn't like loud music, the drug use and the weirdness of the spun out fans. Some people would be turned off by some of those choices but I love it. It gives you the real feel of what those whows were like.

Another example is the Band's Last Waltz movie that has Neil Young with a giant boulder of white hanging out of his nose as he sings Helpless. Scorsese showed it all didn't hold back.

For these reasons I love B. Motel. I think it is hilarious but also bittersweet during some scenes, and I cringe when they show the tweaked out Trey talking to the other guys when he is clearly flying at the edge of space beyond the troposhere or whatever.

The IT doc is a much more of a 'show the band in the best light' type of a thing, imo..
Score: 0

Jerrytheband Permalink
Jerrytheband @buffalo_voice said:
Another example is the Band's Last Waltz movie that has Neil Young with a giant boulder of white hanging out of his nose as he sings Helpless. Scorsese showed it all didn't hold back.

"The infamous cocaine drop hanging from Neil Young's left nostril was airbrushed out by Martin Scorsese. "
Score: 1

Mr_Miner Permalink
Mr_Miner @TheDeerman said:
Dudes, this documentary is out to get the band and make 'em look bad. Especially Trey. To the casual music fan, this film is absolutely designed to make Phish look incredibly egotistical with a fan base that doesn't appreciate quality music. I can't say I'm a fan. Watch it, though.
I don't think so. I thought it was fair and balanced.

Score: 0

Sprachtor Permalink
Sprachtor It is what is it. At this point, it is water under the bridge. They were young guys having fun and maybe they did make asses of themselves. But...they have certainly changed and adopted a more humble, adult approach.

Either way I have learned to separate my favorite artists and what they do on the stage from who they are when not performing. It simply doesn't matter (to me) what they say and do if they can go on stage and put on a good show.

With that being said, I always disliked the video.
Score: 0

JayDubya Permalink
JayDubya @Sprachtor said:
It is what is it. At this point, it is water under the bridge. They were young guys having fun and maybe they did make asses of themselves. But...they have certainly changed and adopted a more humble, adult approach.
I wonder what the band thinks of the movie now.

My daughter likes to throw on old home movies we have of our family when we were all younger. My wife and I cringe because we seem like such idiots. We were very young parents and it shows when we see videos of ourselves from during that time. But, it is what it is and our kids have turned out pretty good regardless.
Score: 1

TheDeerman Permalink
TheDeerman @TheDeerman I'd like to go ahead and disagree with the me from the past. There's a little legitimacy to what you're putting forth, but ultimately it's just a really cool documentary that gives a pretty funny picture of the band and, at times, really dives in to what they actually do onstage every night. I dig it, man. Remember, you showed this to a guy and it really helped turn him on to Phish! "non-phan" seeing the band in a negative light is an unlikely scenario.
Score: 1

revjustin Permalink
revjustin I took my non-phan girlfriend to see this in the theater when it came out. Her first reaction as we left the theater that night was "Man....those guys are dicks." I was taken aback at first, but after I got over the urge to leap to the band's defense, I started to see where she was coming from. It actually made me realize that Phish were human just like the rest of us and that the scene was indeed pretty sketchy to an outsider's perpective.

I recently re-watched the DVD and came away with a much more positive perspective on the film. I mainly attribute that to the fact that I had grown up quite a bit myself and I also knew alot more about the history of Phish and the struggles they had with their backstage scene. The musical parts seemed a lot better to me as well.
Score: 1

meanpete Permalink
bittersweet motel was ok. i found the band interviews to be the best part...the "what's the biggest misconception about mike gordon" question was priceless.

the live footage could be better, but you cant expect a non phan to recignize the top jams of '97.

the fan footage painted some in negative light, but honestly the festival crowd is full of overdrugged wooks, so what do you expect?

i'd like to see a new documentary with a sober band and grown up fanbase.
Score: 0

deBebbler Permalink
deBebbler Cutting the heads off? Really? Still we complain about this?

This is the band that f*cked everyone over who flew to Vegas in 98 to see Dark Side, by playing it the next night. I remember a lot of peeps who shelled out major $$$ and were piiiiiiiissssed off.

This is the band that teases 2001 for three minutes when they have to play an 'A' tune in an out of this world show, and then they play Alaska.

This band has been Lucy to our Charlie Brown for decades. I would have been disappointed if they hadn't cut the heads off in those pictures.

This movie is fun and people need to get over it.

"Sir!!! 10,000, sir!!"
Score: 1

Harry__Hood95 Permalink
Harry__Hood95 I always loved this movie...saw it twice in the theater and have watched the DVD countless times.

Being completely objective, it's not THAT far off in terms of the fanbase from around that time. There were a LOT of spaced out wooks and wasted frat boys at the shows.

I loved the scenes of the band practicing and warming up Roses; and I really loved the whole festival montage. Can only imagine that chaos as the deadline was closing in and there was still a ton of work to get done.
Score: 0

ledzepmaster Permalink
ledzepmaster Sprach was never teased on 8/31/12. That was just super ambiance, you shouldn't have expected 2001.
Score: 0

kipmat Permalink
kipmat @deBebbler said:
This band has been Lucy to our Charlie Brown for decades. I would have been disappointed if they hadn't cut the heads off in those pictures.
This is a great analogy, and one of the best lines of criticism I have read on this forum in at least 2 months. +100.
Score: 0

You must be logged in to leave a comment!

Username

Password

Register | Forgot Password


Back to Forum Back to Forum Oldest First Oldest First Newest First Newest First
Login Register