Back to Forum
Oldest First
Newest First
IMO, the camden 2001 might have been the best I've heard. Any other songs you think have had their best version played in 3.0?
Score: 3
Ocelot
Score: 1
the 12/30/11 2001...hahaha
Score: 0
oh all time? nevermind...
Score: 0
The best Steam, Light and Numberline were played in 3.0.
Score: 10
Score: 2
Really though 11/28/09 Seven Below-Ghost is one of my favorite Phish jams ever.
Score: 1
Hampton FluffheadCamden Sand
Greek Light
Score: 3
Miami BOTT
Score: 7
Hampton Fluffhead comes immediately to mind... also the Gorge Rock and Roll and honestly most recent versions of 46 days (hello Tahoe) have f***ing raged!
Score: 2
Gorge RnR is a great call
Score: 0
Bethel Tech rehearsal waves
Score: 5
Greek Cities and then MSG '11 cities are both great.
Score: 1
Greek Simple
Score: 1
8.7.09 Sneakin Sally and Bathtub Gin
Score: 3
@TheBag said: IMO, the camden 2001 might have been the best I've heard. Any other songs you think have had their best version played in 3.0?I really enjoyed the MJ 2001, and I thought it was a TON of fun, but I wouldn't rate it as my favorite.
I think the Curtain (With) from Camden this summer is my favorite. I'd love to do the reseach, though, if people would like to tell me their contenders!
Score: 1
@TheBag said: IMO, the camden 2001 might have been the best I've heard. Any other songs you think have had their best version played in 3.0?
I would recommend checking out the jamming chart, there are a lot of great 2001's out there
Score: 1
6/11/11 Access Me
Score: 3
10/16/10 Crosseyed
Score: 2
10/16/10 is the best Fluffhead of 3.0, and the best Curtain With IMO (and I know my Curtain Withs)Fucking best show of 3.0 IMO
Score: 5
Score: 2
Superball Mound? Maybe Gorge '11 Roggae... tough to think of many others. To be fair though, there's a combined 19 years of 1.0 vs. only 3 years of 3.0, so you wouldn't expect the list to be that long.
Score: 5
Best 7below is from 3.0
Score: 3
@bs915 said: Really though 11/28/09 Seven Below-Ghost is one of my favorite Phish jams ever.
whoops didn't see your post
Score: 0
@callmethesloth said: Hampton Fluffhead comes immediately to mind... also the Gorge Rock and Roll and honestly most recent versions of 46 days (hello Tahoe) have f***ing raged!Yeh, they blow 46 Days out of the water these days.
I kinda wonder if westbrook is serious about that Access Me since it's such an obscure choice, but in all honesty I friggin' loved it and have been hoping for another since then.
Also, the first thing that comes to mind is The Wedge--it's different now, more punchy.
Score: 0
just going to throw it out there since i don't see it yetghost 12.31.10
i think there are better versions but it was one hell of an IT experience
reba 10.19.10 was pretty tasty too
several more, but we'll get to them at a later date
Score: 1
Score: 2
Walk Away 6/17/10 they ripped that one apart.
Score: 3
Just a thought, but the best Walk Away could well be from 3.0. Starting with the Hartford 2010, they have just been destroying that song. Given it a whole new character than how it was played prior.Of course I'm open to counter-arguments and amazing earlier versions.
Score: 2
/Rad'dNice.
Score: 1
i'll see your coral sky & raise you the 7.29.03 cep
Score: 1
Shit, @johnnyd, nice team work.
Score: 1
@sirhotpants said: I kinda wonder if westbrook is serious about that Access Me since it's such an obscure choice, but in all honesty I friggin' loved it and have been hoping for another since thenThey ditched the snare roll beginning which sounds better.
Roggae SPAC 06-20-2010
DTE Disease
Waves might be 3.0, but 06-20-2004 is pretty hot
Score: 0
I agree on SBIX moundAnd throw in UIC undermind
Score: 0
6.19.04 or 7.3.11 song i heard the ocean sing? guess it depends on my mood cause they're both pretty great
Score: 0
debuted at Hampton.
Score: 1
BDTNL?Jones Beach 2010 or SPAC 2009 or other?
Score: 0
those are the two that immediately come to my mind
Score: 0
Carini, take your pick. It's just better now. Pre-3.0 Carinis are frequently awkward. Of late Mike is just plain commanding. Page is spot on. Trey seems to have found the path for Carini and is not relying on his technical prowess or zany effects. It's more mindful. Frequently a 2.0 Carini just wanders by comparison. On average they are longer too.
Score: 5
that's what she said
Score: 2
@WasteOfTime said: Carini, take your pick. It's just better now. Pre-3.0 Carinis are frequently awkward. Of late Mike is just plain commanding. Page is spot on. Trey seems to have found the path for Carini and is not relying on his technical prowess or zany effects. It's more mindful. Frequently a 2.0 Carini just wanders by comparison. On average they are longer too.I completely agree. 12/28 Carini had me floating on the roof of MSG
Score: 1
Gorge RnR
Camden Curtain With
MSG Meatstick
Camden Sand
Albany Seven Below
Greek Cities?
Hartford Icculus
Camden Curtain With
MSG Meatstick
Camden Sand
Albany Seven Below
Greek Cities?
Hartford Icculus
Score: 1
@GhostlikeSwayze said: @mjrphishhead said:I agree that's the best of all time, I just thought we were talking about 3.010/16/10 Crosseyed11-02-1996
Score: 0
Uummm. Never gets any love. But I'll say it again. 11/24/09.
Score: 1
Charleston 10/16/10 hands down freaking sick !! Doesn't get better
Score: 2
Digging a little deeper, how about...8/7/09 Sneaking Sally
6/18/10 Tweezer Reprise (reprise)
6/20/10 Swept Away/Steep
6/27/10 Saw It Again
8/14/10 What's The Use
8/17/10 Wilson (hilarious)
10/20/10 Guyute & Have Mercy
6/3/11 NICU (happy birthday Cactus)
7/1/11 Quinn The Eskimo
9/4/11 Guy Forget?
Score: 0
How about the Bethel KDF I have not listened to all of them, but this one gets kinda lengthy with a rockin' jam and Trey's shreddage lettuce tossed about the crowd.
Score: 0
lengthwise/maze jb 10rover camden 10
saw it again mpp 10
night nurse manch 10
sneaking sally gorge 09
lifeboy msg 11
reba whistle sbix 11
llama/llama reprise amherst/manch 10 (can't remember..)
carini/f*** your face charlotte 10
twenty years charlotte 10
zep medley/tweezer ac 10
Score: 2
oooooh and no quarter sbix 11(!)
Score: 0
@johnnyd said: Just a thought, but the best Walk Away could well be from 3.0. Starting with the Hartford 2010, they have just been destroying that song. Given it a whole new character than how it was played prior.10/29/98 comes to mind as an earlier stand-out version. First since the Bomb Factory and seems to come spontaneously out of that Reba.
Of course I'm open to counter-arguments and amazing earlier versions.
As of late(3.0) I've seen two Walk Away's and the 10/30/10 version was superior to the 6/18/09 version imo. Understandably so as it had been nearly 9 years coming.
Also, I would like to mention the BDTNL from 6/12/10 Blossom as a 3.0 best. This version evinces the potential of the song and the bands ready-at-will capabilities.
Score: 1
You must be logged in to leave a comment!