Try our mobile site, m.phish.net!

Phish.net: a Project of the Mockingbird Foundation




Back to Forum Back to Forum Oldest First Oldest First Newest First Newest First

Phish Songs That Make You Cry?

12Next →View All

sn0rkel Permalink
Not scared to admit it. Which songs have brought you to tears? Live or just listening..
Off the top of my head:

Dirt
Bug
Diveded Sky
Score: 1

Frizz Permalink
Frizz When Antelope starts up.
Fukin a man. Still miss ya duder.
Score: 3

mmetch Permalink
mmetch Slave
Score: 0

Fenris Permalink
Fenris TTE. Tears of rage when it starts. Tears of joy when it's over.
Score: 3

HARRYHOOD213 Permalink
HARRYHOOD213 Worcester 12...."If I Could"
Score: 5

TwiceBitten Permalink
TwiceBitten It's funny. When I was just coming out of my Phish dark ages (not listening to the band for 7 years, minus attending one show that I did not enjoy) I stumbled upon Tom Marshall's soundcloud. Reading the story of a friendship rekindled through writing Backwards Down the Number Line and then listening to the great demo version, it all just hit home so hard how much this band had meant to me in the past and how much Trey's journey really made connections with my own life's story. Tears were running down my face. I think that's the only time Phish did that to me.
Score: 2

dscott Permalink
Wading
Strange Design
Summer Of '89
...and sometimes Farmhouse
Score: 0

spencur6 Permalink
spencur6 One time I got really drunk and listened to Joy. i cried. Otherwise nothing comes to mind.
Score: 0

johnnyd Phish.net Staff Permalink
johnnyd Dirt towards the end of the Went. Not sure if I literally cried, but for the sake of this thread I might as well have. Coming off that full tour, realizing I was going back to a stressful job, re-engaging with society. Rather than tour - the tiny space to live and breathe.

That was really poignant. Among the most emotional I ever recall being at a show.
Score: 3

_________________________ Permalink
_________________________ During the First Tube encore at Super Ball, a single tear leaked out when I realized I had to go back to society the next day
Score: 4

ypehmish Permalink
ypehmish ALO squirming coil, pages outro
Score: 0

johnnyd Phish.net Staff Permalink
johnnyd @_________________________ said:
During the First Tube encore at Super Ball, a single tear leaked out when I realized I had to go back to society the next day
FWIW, for me at least, that Festy Withdrawal Syndrome has lessened over the years, probably from repeated iterations.

Packing up and saying goodbye at the Clifford Ball was practically debilitating for our whole crew. By Superball, it was more matter of fact. Morning drinks and plenty of goofing around, clean up the site, lots of hugs, and on the road.
Score: 1

_________________________ Permalink
_________________________ @johnnyd said:
@_________________________ said:
During the First Tube encore at Super Ball, a single tear leaked out when I realized I had to go back to society the next day
FWIW, for me at least, that Festy Withdrawal Syndrome has lessened over the years, probably from repeated iterations.

Packing up and saying goodbye at the Clifford Ball was practically debilitating for our whole crew. By Superball, it was more matter of fact. Morning drinks and plenty of goofing around, clean up the site, lots of hugs, and on the road.
Super Ball was my one and only
Score: 0

johnnyd Phish.net Staff Permalink
johnnyd Yup, I get it. That's why I was comparing it to the Clifford Ball for me. First time feeling that way. the first one's gotta be the most powerful.
Shit, if Superball was my first I probably would have been pouring a foundation for a permanent residence by Sunday morning.
Score: 1

BigPimpinNYC Permalink
Not alot of people admit it but everyone in our group was crying by the end of coventry. I still do if wading in the velvet sea comes on.

I have have a few times, last I recall was Joy at Camden, not long after someone in my family passed.
Score: 1

Potato_Sacks Permalink
Potato_Sacks Hydrogen at MSG got me last year. Along with Tube -> Psycho Killer -> Tube from SPAC, tears of raging joy.
Score: 0

jonstolethings Permalink
jonstolethings Curtain With at Deer Creek. Was really hoping for it + emotional times + emotional song + 2nd song slot at my first show= tears
Score: 1

birmy Permalink
birmy Encore, they seems to play it every show...it sucks.

Seriously though a few tunes can bring a teary eyed feeling to me. Joy is one I never want to hear live EVER.

Score: 0

TannisRoot Permalink
TannisRoot theres no crying in phishball

strong men also cry, but if im standing next to a grown man sobbing through Joy or any song, im relocating toute suite

that would be more distracting than any drunk teen on their cell phone
Score: 0

RoverPhish Permalink
velvet sea Coventry
Score: 0

Rutherford_B_Raves Permalink
Rutherford_B_Raves If my mood is right and the music is right then i believe that any Phish song has the potential to bring tears to my eyes.

Live versions that brought tears to my eyes :
-The set ending Squirming Coil from 7/1/2012
-The Corinna from 6/24/2012
Score: 1

phisher131 Permalink
phisher131 Wow,there are a lot of really tough people on here.
Manly men,who would never let themselves cry,even tears of joy.
I have cried at pretty much all of the 80 or shows i've seen since the reunion.
I give all i can to the band.
I am totally unashamed,Phish is magic,the normal rules don't apply.
Score: 4

gskatz Permalink
gskatz Nothing and If I Could both got me at Worcester this summer. If I Could literally gave me inspiration to finish college. I bet I'd cry if I got a Fast Enough for You
Score: 0

Bulletproof Permalink
Bulletproof When the lights went down and they began to play Fluffhead at Hampton in '09 I could not hold back the tears of joy. I wasn't exactly sobbing, but the moment was so emotional for me, the music was great and the vibe too, the tears just started rolling, right there on Page's side in front of a crowded arena. And it was awesome!

That was the only moment I cried at a live show. From time to time when I'm listening to a jam on my headphones and the music is perfect I'll shed a tear or two because there's no way anyone could ever say with words what they say with their music.

That's corny. I'm sorry. ;)
Score: 3

dave25 Permalink
Signd on Super ball first tube knowing it was ending and we had Togo back to real life. My only fest as well
Score: 0

TannisRoot Permalink
TannisRoot @phisher131 said:
Wow,there are a lot of really tough people on here.
Manly men,who would never let themselves cry,even tears of joy.
I have cried at pretty much all of the 80 or shows i've seen since the reunion.
I give all i can to the band.
I am totally unashamed,Phish is magic,the normal rules don't apply.
are you seriously criticizing people who do NOT cry at rock concerts? are you alleging that non-cryers do not "give their all" to the band? are you insane?

there is a vast middle ground between super tough manly men who can not cry and people who weep at every phish show they attend. both ends of that spectrum are equally and UTTERLY ridiculous. IMO, of course.

Score: 2

johnnyd Phish.net Staff Permalink
johnnyd :::adds "baggie of diced onions" to checklist of essential concert gear:::
Score: 5

Freekapaug Permalink
Freekapaug @jonstolethings said:
Curtain With at Deer Creek. Was really hoping for it + emotional times + emotional song + 2nd song slot at my first show= tears
i second that emotion
Score: 0

TheDeputy Permalink
TheDeputy I read about these experiences and I get it, but I've never been brought to tears during the show. I want to say I've been close (to something) and I've felt strong waves of energy, but never tears and not crying. There's usually a moment during every show, even if it's just 30 seconds during some bliss moment or song I love, that I'll feel a strong surge of emotion, energy, adrenaline or something. And it feels great. But it's never came through as tears. just joy and contentment.

sidenote: pulling into a muddy spot and camping area at Coventry Friday morning put some tears in my eyes. We left, like Thursday afternoon and pulled into the grounds around 8am Friday morning. Mike had already made the announcement, it was raining/drizzly and there was no organization/structure/direction. Just cars pulling in wherever. We got to a spot, realized it was kind of wet, and realized we were locked in with no outlet. it sucked and I paniced a bit.
Score: 0

Fenris Permalink
Fenris Uhhhhggg, I've been seeing Phish for 19 years and albeit there may be emotional moments, I've never cried at a Phish show. I've been close at a Grateful Dead show. Does that mean that I'm not getting it for what it is? Enthrall me with your acumen ;)
Score: 1

SicMD Permalink
SicMD reba the curtin with tela
Score: 0

johnnyd Phish.net Staff Permalink
johnnyd @Fenris:
ticket - check
herb - check
water bottle - check
layers - check
poncho - check
setlist book - check
meeting spot with friends - established
baggie of diced onions - FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!!!!!
Score: 0

Fenris Permalink
Fenris Wow. I didn't realize I was in the presence of such glorious winners. Johnnyd, what wil you do do when they stop selling Twinkies? Die of starvation in your mothers basement?
Score: 0

ahull13 Permalink
ahull13 bug
wading in the velvet sea
roggae
lifeboy
Score: 1

katie0801 Permalink
Bug
Show Of Life
Joy
The Wedge
Squirming Coil Endings
Waste
Dirt

So Many in the right moments can make me tear!
Score: 1

twisty_m Permalink
twisty_m Silent in the Morning
Joy

Direct result of a twisty, sad love tale for me.
Score: 2

johnnyd Phish.net Staff Permalink
johnnyd @Fenris said:
Wow. I didn't realize I was in the presence of such glorious winners. Johnnyd, what wil you do do when they stop selling Twinkies? Die of starvation in your mothers basement?
I wasnt insulting you, that was just a joke, based on another comment in the thread. Actually intended with a built-in compliment as to being well prepared for shows. Sorry if it didnt come across that way.

Anyway, I was never a fan of twinkies at all. And my parents basement remains a pretty dope spot to hang out, given the right company.
Score: 1

Fenris Permalink
Fenris My bad. I took the FU to heart. Again, my bad. Just waiting for the next show :)
Score: 1

johnnyd Phish.net Staff Permalink
johnnyd Oh, yeah. Like I meant that you brought all the important stuff, but got trolled (the FFFFUUU internet meme guy) by forgetting a bag of onions, leaving you thusly unable to cry as necessary or expected. Thats all. Dumb joke. (Which, alas, is a big part of my game.)
Score: 0

12Next →View All

You must be logged in to leave a comment!

Username

Password

Register | Forgot Password


Back to Forum Back to Forum Oldest First Oldest First Newest First Newest First
Login Register