looking forward to raging the tenth anniversary of the Phirst Return in little more than a month
My first show :-) Actually scored two pairs of tickets off ticketmaster at my school. There was about 25 of us trying I was the only person who got them. I still can't believe that. Anyway show was awesome. This is my favorite version of piper I've ever heard and it's the first song I ever heard them play live! I remember being very confused during the tom hanks Wilson thing. Solid show!
That was my only time I've been to NYC. I was 19 drove out from Chicago with 3 buddies in a shitty two door old Toyota Tercel but good times. Really wanted to get back this year for the tenth anniversary of my first show (and my next show is #40) but just wasn't possible.
It was a beautiful day in NYC that day. no winter coat needed...just perfect outside. scored 3 sugar cubes out front. energy before the show was crazy. Lots of songs relating to them being "back". Piper was a great opener...no one called that and the intro allowed the crowd to go crazy while not missing much music. It was my first mound and because of that it was the highlight of the first set for me. It was exciting to see some of the new tunes...waves was cool but didn't feel right as a set opener. The divided sky pause was bananas. Seven below with the snow was amazing. Went w a crew of 6 people and really had a great time. Just pure bliss...everyone was happy that phish was back. Had a room on broadway...stayed up all night, talking to friends who were home/at other shows. Went home for a day then made it down to hampton for those shows.
No one could walk into this show without much anticipation....the Garden and its sonic splendor and history...NYE ....return from Hiatus...3 Hampton shows to follow...
Yes, Piper energy was crazy. Musically, whole show was ok. Cool event to be a part of but the band could have and should have delivered epic b/c that's what the moment called for.
Piper was almost too much cacophony and chaos to really resonate. Seven Below was surreal and will always be my memory of the evening. Time Loves a Hero was a nice touch but ending the 3rd set with Walls (when it was despised by most phans) and a Wading encore (despised by most phans until Page cried at Coventry) with nothing else....demonstrated how the band wasn't really ready for it (as clearly demonstrated in Hampton the following run).
So, cool to be a part of but quite disappointing considering the Band had a history of delivering in this type of moment and considering the difficulty getting into the bldg (along with your crew of friends) made this a meh evening for me.
Yes, Piper energy was crazy. Musically, whole show was ok. Cool event to be a part of but the band could have and should have delivered epic b/c that's what the moment called for.
Piper was almost too much cacophony and chaos to really resonate. Seven Below was surreal and will always be my memory of the evening. Time Loves a Hero was a nice touch but ending the 3rd set with Walls (when it was despised by most phans) and a Wading encore (despised by most phans until Page cried at Coventry) with nothing else....demonstrated how the band wasn't really ready for it (as clearly demonstrated in Hampton the following run).
So, cool to be a part of but quite disappointing considering the Band had a history of delivering in this type of moment and considering the difficulty getting into the bldg (along with your crew of friends) made this a meh evening for me.
Fun
seven below snowfall inside msg.
Heard mound and time loves a hero at my first show. Didn't hear mound again until this year at deer creek (36th show) then again in the STL(39th)! Stats are crazy. Dying to hear time lives a hero again that will break my longest streak I think. Or any little feat, but that night made me love that song forever!
@funk_lin said:
Time Loves a Hero was a nice touch but ending the 3rd set with Walls (when it was despised by most phans) and a Wading encore (despised by most phans until Page cried at Coventry) with nothing else....demonstrated how the band wasn't really ready for it (as clearly demonstrated in Hampton the following run).Those 2 songs would have made the night for me. Seriously. They hold up quite nicely on tape, too. Top-notch, cathartic version of Wading. However, I guess since you don't like those songs it means that the band was unprepared for the occasion.
but ending the 3rd set with Walls (when it was despised by most phans)How was Walls "despised by most phans" when it's 'debut' was on the Round Room album mere WEEKS before 12/31/02?
Personally, I found Walls, and Waves, to be QUITE epic, and was more than thrilled to hear its live debut on 12/31/02
...I was with 20+ friends for 12/31/02 (easily over 1000 shows between us) and not a single one of us found the show anything more than fun to be with each other. Collectively found it musically meh. If you don't agree....good for you. That's the beauty of art.
Don't get me wrong: I was very happy to be there ...never said I wasn't. Still go see the band year after year 125+ shows and counting.....
What doesn't change year after year on these boards: Express your opinion contrary to someone's personal opinion/experience and people just can't handle it...almost like it's an attack on their emotional connection. Relax...art is subjective. From rmp to pt to .net ...same as it ever was .... same as it ever was.
See you on tour this summer folks...
Don't get me wrong: I was very happy to be there ...never said I wasn't. Still go see the band year after year 125+ shows and counting.....
What doesn't change year after year on these boards: Express your opinion contrary to someone's personal opinion/experience and people just can't handle it...almost like it's an attack on their emotional connection. Relax...art is subjective. From rmp to pt to .net ...same as it ever was .... same as it ever was.
See you on tour this summer folks...
- Piper was good, but it came off as a slightly less-developed version of the Piper from Vegas six weeks later. They even revisit and flesh out TWO of the themes introduced in the MSG jam in that one!
- Waves, Jim, Bowie, Walls Of The Cave, and even Taste all show off that great textured '03 interwoven jamming fabric, in surprisingly mature form... all of these versions stand up to any I've heard from 2003-04. great major-key jam space in Bowie, and an excellent segue from Jim > Time Loves A Hero.
- on my SBD recording, it sounds like Taste should have segued out of something, but... it doesn't. there's a good minute of quiet and crowd noise at the end of Time Loves A Hero, and then Taste starts, but with a weird abrupt cymbal wash that makes me think there's something missing. anybody else notice this?
@funk_lin said:
...I was with 20+ friends for 12/31/02 (easily over 1000 shows between us) and not a single one of us found the show anything more than fun to be with each other. Collectively found it musically meh. If you don't agree....good for you. That's the beauty of art.Some people disagree, but the point is that you projected your experience onto the band. That's kind of absurd, when you think about it. Your negative opinion about the song selection doesn't mean any more than my favorable opinion about it in terms of figuring out whether the band was prepared for rising to the occasion.
Don't get me wrong: I was very happy to be there ...never said I wasn't. Still go see the band year after year 125+ shows and counting.....
What doesn't change year after year on these boards: Express your opinion contrary to someone's personal opinion/experience and people just can't handle it...almost like it's an attack on their emotional connection. Relax...art is subjective. From rmp to pt to .net ...same as it ever was .... same as it ever was.
See you on tour this summer folks...
I got a single ticketmaster ticket through my rural dsl connection. Then, a friend got the Bank of America box so I traded up for that (got another dear friend into the building as well). The scene heading in was intense, we walked up the wrong ramp, then swam against traffic to find the uncrowded escalator to the suites. Swimming against that traffic with 10-12 people was by far the hardest movement through a Phish crowd I've ever done. We raged the box hard, someone got engaged (now divorced), we had table service, it was really over the top and kind of indicative of 2.0 in general (it would not be the last time we had the BofA suite), for us and perhaps the band. Too much of anything ain't good for nobody. You better believe it.
The show was good. I treated it like a start of something bigger. Which it was. There was so much more to come in the year to follow. I liked the bookends of Piper and WOTC. Waves> Divided just sounds cool. That Waves is still top 5 and a great contender for best debut. Carini was nasty.
Bill Walton (can neither confirm nor deny it was him) was freaking out in the front row to Wading. Raising his big paws up into the air triumphantly in the shape of giant energy ball. WTFUck? Too funny. Noob. That was unexpected highlight of the box high above the stage, the ability to mock people below during the slow jams. Always dance like no one is watching, go ahead, it's fine because, we're watching and it's hilarious.
We had a message on on our hotel room phone when we got back. All the message said was...Mouuuund.
The show was good. I treated it like a start of something bigger. Which it was. There was so much more to come in the year to follow. I liked the bookends of Piper and WOTC. Waves> Divided just sounds cool. That Waves is still top 5 and a great contender for best debut. Carini was nasty.
Bill Walton (can neither confirm nor deny it was him) was freaking out in the front row to Wading. Raising his big paws up into the air triumphantly in the shape of giant energy ball. WTFUck? Too funny. Noob. That was unexpected highlight of the box high above the stage, the ability to mock people below during the slow jams. Always dance like no one is watching, go ahead, it's fine because, we're watching and it's hilarious.
We had a message on on our hotel room phone when we got back. All the message said was...Mouuuund.

Back to Forum
Oldest First
Newest First