@Dog_Faced_Boy said:

The Roggae Jamming Chart is now up on the site. Up until late 2000, the jam section of Roggae was played in a generally consistent and similar manner. Since then, the jam section has become more interesting and varied. To view the Jamming Chart for Roggae, go to the Jamming Charts page, or simply click here. Enjoy.

You, sir, have entered Beast mode.

Sorry, but I think there's a glaring omission here -- the Roggae from 10/31/98 is just blissful and I know there's a lot of other fans of this version, too.

@ProfPhan - 10/31/98 is a great version, but it's also very typical compared to most other versions from this period. Listen to 11/20/98, for example, and I think you'll find the jam at this point was fairly standard. It really wasn't until late 2000 when the band started to experiment with the jam section and differentiate. The Jam Chart illustrates versions that are noticeably different from a "standard, typically great" version. Hope that helps. If you still feel strongly that 10/31/98 should be added, let me know.

Phil

I'm planning to publish Free, Theme From The Bottom, Divided Sky and Maze next weekend. The following weekend, I plan to publish Suzy Greenberg, Prince Caspian, Llama, and The Mango Song. There is also a draft chart for Fee that will be published at some point.

@Dog_Faced_Boy said:

@ProfPhan - 10/31/98 is a great version, but it's also very typical compared to most other versions from this period. Listen to 11/20/98, for example, and I think you'll find the jam at this point was fairly standard. It really wasn't until late 2000 when the band started to experiment with the jam section and differentiate. The Jam Chart illustrates versions that are noticeably different from a "standard, typically great" version. Hope that helps. If you still feel strongly that 10/31/98 should be added, let me know.

Phil

Thanks for your response.

Just wondering if anyone else was on board with my thoughts of the 10/31/98 as an exceptional reading worth noting?

I've spent many a summer's night (at dusk) listening to that version, and the final 4:30 just seems so suited as a soundtrack for a sunset.

You are an animal, @Dog_Faced_Boy.
Thanks.

Thanks @dog_faced_BOY and others who complete these charts, I currently don't need it but im glad you made it for my future reference!

@johnnyd said:

You are an animal, @Dog_Faced_Boy.
Thanks.

I believe he's technically part animal, part boy...

@ProfPhan said:

@Dog_Faced_Boy said:

@ProfPhan - 10/31/98 is a great version, but it's also very typical compared to most other versions from this period. Listen to 11/20/98, for example, and I think you'll find the jam at this point was fairly standard. It really wasn't until late 2000 when the band started to experiment with the jam section and differentiate. The Jam Chart illustrates versions that are noticeably different from a "standard, typically great" version. Hope that helps. If you still feel strongly that 10/31/98 should be added, let me know. Phil

Thanks for your response. Just wondering if anyone else was on board with my thoughts of the 10/31/98 as an exceptional reading worth noting? I've spent many a summer's night (at dusk) listening to that version, and the final 4:30 just seems so suited as a soundtrack for a sunset.

im on board with you dude. it is one of my favorite phish recordings. so beautiful...just like a sunset as you said. while it is standard, i think its worthy of the chart.