Try our mobile site, m.phish.net!

Phish.net: a Project of the Mockingbird Foundation




Back to Forum Back to Forum Oldest First Oldest First Newest First Newest First

Phish fan opinions....(song etc...)

Palmer Permalink
Palmer Reba, With or without the Whistling?
You Enjoy Myself, With or without the vocal jam?
Mike's Song > Simple > Weekapaug Groove?
or
Mike's Song > Hydrogen > Weekapaug Groove?
Piper with the slow circa 1998 build or current version?
Score: 0

spencur6 Permalink
spencur6 Reba w/whistle
Yem w/vocal
Mikes> undecided> Weekapaug
Piper circa 98
Score: 0

dscott Permalink
With
With
Hydrogen
Slow Build

...and Curtain With (duh!!!)
Score: 0

the_Crested_Hogchoker Permalink
the_Crested_Hogchoker Hold the whistling and vocal jam,
With the With
Hydrogen
Slow on the Piper
Score: 0

careful_w_that_axe_Miller Permalink
careful_w_that_axe_Miller It depends on Reba and YEM, lately I've been digging the vocal jam, but as with the whistle in Reba it can slow it down a bit which I do not dig.

Mikes groove with IAH (longer the better on IAH, wouid love to hear that played into)
Simple can stand alone imo

Piper is a great song anyway you cut it.

Score: 0

twisty_m Permalink
twisty_m Reba - without whistle
You Enjoy Myself- with vocal
Mike's Song > w/Hydrogen
Piper- slow
Score: 0

MiguelSanchez Permalink
MiguelSanchez Reba- don't care
Yem- w/o I don't like the vocal jam. I would much rather a -> into something
Mikes-> hydro-> paugh
Piper- whatever gets the job done. In not f***ing around.
Curtain w/- all day long
Score: 0

Colonel_DanTeca Permalink
Definitely whistling, I've still haven't gotten a Reba the whistling ending I feel jipped.
YEM always should have the vocal jam
Mike's Song> Hydrogen or Simple both are cool
Piper in any way shape or form is awesome
Score: 1

spencur6 Permalink
spencur6 to amend my earlier comment.
curtain with.
Score: 0

ol_dirty Permalink
Piper slow
reba with
yem whatever, by at the point the song has ended,
mikes groove is best with h2 and simple and catapult and 2001 and all other whatever they want to toss in there
Score: 0

fishman4 Permalink
fishman4 It depends on the Reba jam honestly. If it's intensely beautiful than no whistle if it's more fun than gorgeous than with whistle.
Definitely always include the YEM vocal jam. Love it every time.
I definitely prefer hydrogen in the middle, but again it depends on how the Mike's jam is going.
Slow build in Piper all the way!
Score: 0

MiguelSanchez Permalink
MiguelSanchez If you are only paying attention to the whistling, you are not paying attention to the Reba.
Score: 1

elton_john Permalink
elton_john Good lord...when was the last YEM without a vocal jam?
Score: 1

pnutmcsnappy Permalink
pnutmcsnappy @Palmer said:
Reba, With or without the Whistling?
You Enjoy Myself, With or without the vocal jam?
Mike's Song > Simple > Weekapaug Groove?
or
Mike's Song > Hydrogen > Weekapaug Groove?
Piper with the slow circa 1998 build or current version?
Without
With
Simple
Slow
Score: 0

gay4pacman Permalink
gay4pacman with
with
simple
slooooow
Score: 0

noodlesmcintosh Permalink
If i'm there, w/ if i'm not w/o
If i'm there, w/ if i'm not w/o
hydrogen, but i like simple, no preference i guess
slow build up all the way
Score: 0

jerryguscia Permalink
jerryguscia Reba = With
YEM = Can't decide
Mike's Song > Hydrogen > Weekapaug
Piper = Innnnntrooooo
Curtain (With)

Good jams or good segues? (like 12/06 vs 12/07)
Score: 0

dkast85 Permalink
dkast85 @Mr_Incompletely said:
Curtain with or without
that is like asking, "Bentley with the 10 million dollar mansion or without?"
Score: 1

You must be logged in to leave a comment!

Username

Password

Register | Forgot Password


Back to Forum Back to Forum Oldest First Oldest First Newest First Newest First
Login Register