Back to Forum
Oldest First
Newest First
Best 1.0 bag in your opinion.
Score: 0
12-30-97, Biased, I was there and I've been listening to the 97 December Holiday run A LOT lately. That AC/DC Bag is unreal.
Score: 0
12-30-97
Score: 0
9/14
Score: 0
9/14/99
Score: 0
9/14/99 for me but I really love them all. You're forgetting a couple versions though, OP. 11/21/97 & 8/9/98
Score: 0
12/30/97 is one of the better Phish jams ever, really. I love 9/14/99 but I personally gotta go for the MSG reigning champ.
Score: 0
Why not all three???
Score: 3
9/14/99
Score: 0
I was at all 3. They each have their own great and distinct qualities.
3 way tie!
3 way tie!
Score: 2
8.9.98 /thread
Score: 0
09/14/99 has one of the most hypnotic jam segments I've ever heard Phish play. It is completely.... unique.
But I do love the funk of 12/30/97.
But I do love the funk of 12/30/97.
Score: 1
@RR1994 said: 09/14/99 has one of the most hypnotic jam segments I've ever heard Phish play. It is completely.... unique.
But I do love the funk of 12/30/97.
Exactly. I love, LOVE, the funk but there's something about the way that Boise Bag grabs ahold of you
Score: 0
Heard, Heard and aheard!!
Score: 0
I dunno about "the best" but those are all great versions. I could pick my fav AC/DC Bag from any of those 3 depending on what mood I'm in. I usually go with 12.30.97 but since you left it off your list, and I'm not sure if you did so intentionally, why not check out 8.9.98 from VA Beach, like Ron suggested. It's a great listen as well, from a great show, that gets often overshadowed by the Terrapin Station. Hopefully that show gets released some day, cause it's really an awesome show and then the icing on the cake with the encore. And yes, I'm biased cause I was there, dead center, 20 or so rows back. A magical night. I actually called the AC/DC Bag second set opener during the setbreak. Mad high fives from my whole row! And boy did they deliver!!!
Score: 0
Score: 3
I place 9/14/99 with 5/22/00 RCMH ghost... I believe these are the two best jams the band has ever played. Others may argue differently. 
Pooty ==== lucky dog!!!
Score: 0
12-30 for me
Score: 1
Score: 0
Boise Bag
Score: 0
12/30/97 no contest for me. It might be the best jam of 97.
Score: 0
Yeah 12/30/97. I haven't listened to the others but the answer to any question involving 12/30/97 is always 12/30/97.
::remembers the magic::
::masterbates::
::remembers the magic::
::masterbates::
Score: 0
@jmponder said:
9/14/99 for me but I really love them all. You're forgetting a couple versions though, OP. 11/21/97 & 8/9/98GREAT call on the 8/9/98 Bag. I was there and loving itQ
Score: 0
12/30/97
Score: 0
@MiguelSanchez said: @bostonron said:double no.8.9.98 /threadNo
None of these, as great as they are, compare to 12/30/97. I know that music is subjective and all that, but poppy please! The Bag from MSG 97 is one of Phish's finest moments.....EVER! It makes 8/9/98 sound like a boring Numberline jam.
Score: 1
12-30-97 almost has a ghost-like sound to it around the 12 min mark
Score: 0
@Slothberries said: @MiguelSanchez said:Triple stamped no..@bostonron said:double no.8.9.98 /threadNo
None of these, as great as they are, compare to 12/30/97. I know that music is subjective and all that, but poppy please! The Bag from MSG 97 is one of Phish's finest moments.....EVER! It makes 8/9/98 sound like a boring Numberline jam.
While it's a good jam...almost has a riverport gin sound to it..but the 12/30/97 version just takes you on a couple wild rides before ending up in mcgrupp..
Score: 0
@forbin1 said: @Slothberries said:yeah, its a solid jam. Definitely reminds me of riverport.@MiguelSanchez said:Triple stamped no..@bostonron said:double no.8.9.98 /threadNo
None of these, as great as they are, compare to 12/30/97. I know that music is subjective and all that, but poppy please! The Bag from MSG 97 is one of Phish's finest moments.....EVER! It makes 8/9/98 sound like a boring Numberline jam.
While it's a good jam...almost has a riverport gin sound to it..but the 12/30/97 version just takes you on a couple wild rides before ending up in mcgrupp..
That 97 Bag is just a beast...
Score: 0
@Slothberries said: @MiguelSanchez said:number line jam.... BURN!!@bostonron said:double no.8.9.98 /threadNo
None of these, as great as they are, compare to 12/30/97. I know that music is subjective and all that, but poppy please! The Bag from MSG 97 is one of Phish's finest moments.....EVER! It makes 8/9/98 sound like a boring Numberline jam.
Score: 0
You must be logged in to leave a comment!