Back to Forum
Oldest First
Newest First
Personally, I'd love for them to play an album from 1983. So many great options from that year:Murmur
Thriller
Violent Femmes
War
Synchronicity
Pyromania
Genesis
Let's Dance
Shout at the Devil
Punch the Clock
Score: 2
I'd love to see Meddle or American Beauty.
Score: 2
You know what? I'd like them to go outside their comfort zone and do an album like Return to Cookie Mountain. Granted, they probably couldn't pull off all the vocals, but they'd do well enough (it's not like they butcher Golden Age or anything), and the really thick and meaty polyrhythmic anthems of TV on the Radio fit this incarnation of Phish to a T (again, see Golden Age). And, let's be honest, they've been so beholden to classic rock over their careers and especially their Halloween shows, this just might help them find yet another level of performance. The last time they covered an album that was just over a decade old at the time, it didn't turn out too badly...ETA: I do love that album, but good Jesus does that name suck.
Score: 1
How about Atlantic City?
Score: 0
Score: 0
Actually, the more I think about it the more I'm enamored with Phish doing an album from the last decade or so. Imagine what they could do with Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix? A 15+ minute jam out of Lizstomania? Si, mas bueno. Or go the MGB route and do In Rainbows (a great album that also wouldn't carry the same cultural freight that Kid A would)? Hell, if you want to stay more trad-rock, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot would also be a great choice - there's a lot of spaciness in that album anyway, and Wilco jams those songs out on stage, so surely Phish could as well. The possibilities are endless.
Score: 0
Zepp III or physical graffiti, my bloody valentine only shallow, maybe a kinks album? How about GRATEFUL DEAD its long over due and BLUES FOR ALLAH would more than some up Halloween traditions
Score: 0
Meddle
Score: 1
we are ready for a dead album.
Score: 4
@n00b100 said: Actually, the more I think about it the more I'm enamored with Phish doing an album from the last decade or so.I think a recent album would be great musically, but it wouldn't be an album from the year that they formed, which would be the whole point of the 1983 thing and all.
Score: 0
I'm pulling hard for a Midwest Halloween. While I'm making wish list...1) zeppelin- physical graffiti
2) ween- white pepper
3) Floyd- animals
Score: 3
Radiohead- OK Computer or Kid ANeil Young and Crazy Horse- Rust Never Sleeps
Neil Young-Tonight's The Night
Neutral Milk Hotel- In The Aeroplane Over The Sea
Led Zeppelin 1
Grateful Dead-Europe '72
Score: 0
Aja
Score: 4
Score: 0
@MiguelSanchez said: I'm pulling hard for a Midwest Halloween. While I'm making wish list...Would LOVE to hear them do Animals. One of my favorite albums of all time. On average, I listen to it in its entirety 3-4 times a week. Any Zeppelin album would be good.
1) zeppelin- physical graffiti
2) ween- white pepper
3) Floyd- animals
Score: 0
@Jerrytheband said: Radiohead- OK Computer or Kid A
Neil Young and Crazy Horse- Rust Never Sleeps
Neil Young-Tonight's The Night
Neutral Milk Hotel- In The Aeroplane Over The Sea
Led Zeppelin 1
Grateful Dead-Europe '72
Add
My Bloody Valentine- Loveless
Score: 1
WARREN ZEVON - EXCITABLE BOY
Score: 4
@SconyMack said: @MiguelSanchez said:Animals is easily in my top 3 rock albums. I probably roll through it 3-4 times a month.I'm pulling hard for a Midwest Halloween. While I'm making wish list...Would LOVE to hear them do Animals. One of my favorite albums of all time. On average, I listen to it in its entirety 3-4 times a week. Any Zeppelin album would be good.
1) zeppelin- physical graffiti
2) ween- white pepper
3) Floyd- animals
Score: 0
Weeper blue album cover, short. Good lots of fun.
Score: 0
Weezer
Score: 0
Make my funk da P-Phunk, we gonna get phunked up?
Score: 0
Set I: JuntaSet II: Rift
Set III: Billy Breathes
...or some such thing.
Score: 1
Classic: Houses of the HolyRecent: @n00b100 said:
Hell, if you want to stay more trad-rock, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot would also be a great choice - there's a lot of spaciness in that album anyway, and Wilco jams those songs out on stage, so surely Phish could as well.Both these unlikely choices are sheer genius.
Score: 0
Traveler, anybody?
Score: 1
Meddle
Ziggy Stardust
Overnight Sensation or Apostrophe
Graceland
Piper At The Gates Of Dawn would be f***ing epic but I don't see it happening. My other picks I could imagine.
Ziggy Stardust
Overnight Sensation or Apostrophe
Graceland
Piper At The Gates Of Dawn would be f***ing epic but I don't see it happening. My other picks I could imagine.
Score: 0
I'm sorry, Trey would never pull off In My Time of Dying.Plus the double album would require a mammoth 2nd set... or better yet, a 4th set. I'd love to see it happen though.
If they were going to do Zep, they would have done II, IV, or Houses. I'd still love to see it happen though.
Score: 0
Score: 0
Abbey Road
Score: 0
@Zutroy said: Personally, I'd love for them to play an album from 1983. So many great options from that year:Speaking in Tongues (1983)
Score: 0
@Penn42 said: @ypehmish said:This is in my top 3 albums of all time.AjaI'd flip my shit.
Dark side of the moon
Aja
House of the Holy
Score: 0
Score: 0
HIGHWAY TO HELL OR BACK IN BLACK !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Score: -1
@ledzepmaster said:
I'm sorry, Trey would never pull off In My Time of Dying.They did a double album in '94, '95, & 2010 on Halloween
Plus the double album would require a mammoth 2nd set... or better yet, a 4th set. I'd love to see it happen though.
If they were going to do Zep, they would have done II, IV, or Houses. I'd still love to see it happen though.
Score: 1
@gonephishn11 said: @ledzepmaster said:Zep songs are longer than Beatles songs. Also I did not know the Little Feat costume was a double album.I'm sorry, Trey would never pull off In My Time of Dying.They did a double album in '94, '95, & 2010 on Halloween
Plus the double album would require a mammoth 2nd set... or better yet, a 4th set. I'd love to see it happen though.
If they were going to do Zep, they would have done II, IV, or Houses. I'd still love to see it happen though.
Score: 0
Europe '72 would be kind of weird because it's a live album... though listening to it, it's so god damn spot on it's almost hard to tell!
Score: 0
@ucpete said: Europe '72 would be kind of weird because it's a live album... though listening to it, it's so god damn spot on it's almost hard to tell!
Waiting for Columbus was a live album
Score: 0
@n00b100 said: The last time they covered an album that was just over a decade old at the time, it didn't turn out too badly...Which album would that be?? I'm having a hard time thinking of any Phish Halloween Costume that was a more recent album. Remain in Light came out in 1980 so it was 16 years since its release-- hardly "recent" especially when you consider the album came out before Phish even existed...
Score: 0
@Jerrytheband said: @ucpete said:Ah, good point! Totally spaced that. Then again I'm still not familiar with Little Feat's music except for a few of the more common Phish covers...Europe '72 would be kind of weird because it's a live album... though listening to it, it's so god damn spot on it's almost hard to tell!
Waiting for Columbus was a live album
Score: 0
I think it'd be kinda cool if they played their first (known set) show. Proud Mary would be sick.
Score: 0
Uhhhhhhh Fear of music.
Score: 1
Perform a Green Day album. That way, the set will take 18 minutes and they can use the rest of the time for Phish stuff.
Score: 0
can - tago mago
Score: 0
@ledzepmaster said: @gonephishn11 said:there's a lot more songs on the white album than there are on physical graffiti. a double album is a double album.@ledzepmaster said:Zep songs are longer than Beatles songs. Also I did not know the Little Feat costume was a double album.I'm sorry, Trey would never pull off In My Time of Dying.They did a double album in '94, '95, & 2010 on Halloween
Plus the double album would require a mammoth 2nd set... or better yet, a 4th set. I'd love to see it happen though.
If they were going to do Zep, they would have done II, IV, or Houses. I'd still love to see it happen though.
Score: 1
The doors first album
Score: 0
I think classic LPs are best. I considered Waiting for Columbus a classic since I listened to it all through high school. I think my first choice right now would be Meddle.
Score: 0
I chuckled pretty hard at this
Score: 0
Score: 0
Just because I'm grooving to it today - and I know it will never happen.The Cars - the Cars 1978...man that would be saweet!