Rank the 10 best phish songs

UnplugUrSelfFromTheMatrix 1/27/13 7:07 pm

The author has chosen to remove all text from this comment.

Score: 0

Abrahm 1/27/13 7:13 pm

Survey was a little tough to navigate

so..

1.) Reba
2.) Split Open and Melt
3.) Tweezer
4.) Ghost
5.) Antelope
6.) Stash
7.) YEM
8.) Hood
9.) Lizards
10.) Bowie

Score: 3

herbpowell 1/27/13 7:22 pm

harpua ahem

Score: 0

Shukky 1/27/13 7:25 pm

Hood
Yem
Tweezer
Curtain With
Chalkdust
Antelope
Ghost
Bowie
Mikes Song
First Tube

Score: 0

Phaster 1/27/13 7:29 pm

1. Wolfman's
2. YEM
3. Antelope
4. Bowie
5. Hood
6. Tweezer
7. Mike's>
8. Weekapaug
9. character zero
10. Coil

Score: 0

ledzepmaster 1/27/13 7:42 pm

YEM
Reba
Divided Sky
Fluffhead
Hood
Lizards
Bowie
Curtain With
Esther
It's Ice

Score: 2

JNap05 1/27/13 8:00 pm

Ill do ten favorite songs off the top of my head...I'm sure ill forget stuff:

1) YEM
2) DWD
3) Ghost
4) Antelope
5) Tweezer
6) Lizards
7) Sand
8) Mikes
9) My Friend
10) Carini

Score: 2

parrott56 1/27/13 8:05 pm

God, you all are such Phish classicists! Almost no picks composed after 1990! [edit: that remark before I saw post directly before mine] Okay, here's mine (list and order probably not definitive, etc.):

Hood
SOAMelt
Vultures
Waves
Ghost
Taste
BOAF
Bowie
Gin
Stash

Score: 0

feelgoodVT 1/27/13 8:06 pm

Top 3:

1.Hood
2.YEM
3.Slave

Score: 0

careful_w_that_axe_Miller 1/27/13 8:09 pm

people should not be allowed to have wrong opinions

Score: 5

chaizul 1/27/13 8:40 pm

Unless antelope isn't on ur list

Score: 1

LedZeppelin 1/27/13 9:30 pm

1. Forbin's> Mockingbird
2. YEM
3. Reba
4. Guyute
5. Foam
6. Esther
7. McGrupp
8. TTE
9. Weigh
10. Round Room

Score: 1

kipmat 1/27/13 9:53 pm

1. Tweezer
2. You Enjoy Myself
3. Reba
4. Chalk Dust Torture
5. Harry Hood
6. Walls of the Cave
7. Down With Disease
8. Light
9. Ghost
10. Theme From The Bottom

Score: 1

phishiNYG 1/27/13 9:59 pm

Carini
Ocelot
Chalkdust
Kung
Sneakin Sally
Undermind
Character Zero
Kill Devil Falls
Esther
Run Like A Antelope

Score: 3

IntoYesterday 1/27/13 10:02 pm

The Curtain With
YEM
Forbin> Mockingbird
Harry Hood
Divided Sky
Reba
Run Like An Antelope
Lizards
Harpua
Walls of the Cave

Honorable mention to All Things Reconsidered, Guyute, and many I'm forgetting.

Score: 1

gordonsmule 1/27/13 10:05 pm

no PYITE?

Score: 1

maplesteam 1/28/13 12:05 am

why?

Score: 1

Penn42 1/28/13 12:46 am

Any list that doesn't have YEM at number 1 (or at least the top 3) is wrong.

Score: 1

me_no_are_no_nice_guy 1/28/13 12:59 am

Impossible to do with no criteria given.

Score: 2

dkast85 1/28/13 1:19 am

my personal opinion

1. Curtain With
2. You Enjoy Myself
3. Reba
4. Harry Hood
5. Slave to the Traffic Light
6. Fluffhead
7. David Bowie
8. Run Like an Antelope
9. Divided Sky
10. Ghost

Score: 2

TheArgus 1/28/13 1:37 am

IMO

1. Curtain With
2. YEM
3. Hood
4. Fluffhead
4. Reba
5. Slave
6. Mikes-> .....-> Paug
7. Maze
8. Tweezer
9. Possum
10. Foam

I am 100% aware that my list lacks D-Sky, Bowie, Antelope, and a few others many would consider to be a given. Wanna fight about it?

Score: 2

SicMD 1/28/13 11:02 am

Lizards
SOAM
Tela
Curtin with
Reba
Antelope
Bowie
Coil
YEM
CaverN
Chalkdust

Score: 1

SicMD 1/28/13 11:02 am

And LLAMA

Score: 1

AllForYourDelight 1/28/13 1:50 pm

Hood
Stash
Chalk Dust
Tela
YEM
DAvid Bowie
Maze
Limb by Limb
Mound
Reba

Score: 1

phisher131 1/28/13 3:05 pm

Piper
Divided Sky
YEM
Harpua
Tela-long version
Mikes/Weekapaug
Antelope
Fluffhead
Song i heard the Ocean Sing
Lizards

Score: 0

mangobrain 1/28/13 3:17 pm

@LedZeppelin and @TheArgus, I really appreciate your inclusion of Foam, also one of my favorite tunes.

Score: 1

Phishin90 1/28/13 3:24 pm

1. Run Like an Antelope
2. Harry Hood
3. YEM
4. Tweezer
5. Reba
6. Divided Sky
7. David Bowie
8. Fluffhead
9. Mikes Groove
10. Maze

Score: 0

Fikus 1/28/13 3:32 pm

1. YEM
2. Antelope
3. Slave
4. Tweezer
5. Disease
6. Bowie
7. Ghost
8. Taste
9. Fee
10. Cavern

This could change at any moment.

Score: 0

me_no_are_no_nice_guy 1/28/13 3:39 pm

How are any of you making lists? What criteria are you using? What are your lists based on? Just your favorites?

Score: 0

TheArgus 1/28/13 3:42 pm

@me_no_are_no_nice_guy said:

How are any of you making lists? What criteria are you using? What are your lists based on? Just your favorites?

I'd say ask consult the OP, but he is lacking in the instructions department. I wouldn't necessarily say my list is based soley on favorites, if it was there would be a few different tunes in there. It is subjective as hell though

Score: 0

Fikus 1/28/13 4:00 pm

My list is more or less my favorites tempered by the following:
1. Songs that sum up Phish to me (e.g. YEM, Slave)
2. Songs that consistently go different places
3. Songs I could see every show.

Score: 0

TheEmperorJoker 1/28/13 5:14 pm

Divided Sky, Antelope, Slave, Bowie, YEM

I'm going to interpret this challenge as the 10 most consistently amazing live songs of all time (for me):

1.Tweezer
2.Ghost
3.Harry Hood
4.Harpua
5.Bathtub Gin
6.Light
7.Reba
8.Down with Disease
9.David Bowie
10.Run Like an Antelope

Good lord it was hard to leave Slave and YEM off that list!!!!!!!!

Score: 0

tufan57 1/28/13 5:17 pm

It always changes, but I will try.

1. You Enjoy Myself
2. Harry Hood
3. Slave to the Traffic Light
4. Ghost
5. David Bowie
6. Waste
7. Chalkdust Torture
8. Tweezer
9. Possum
10. 2001

Score: 0

MirthBeatenWorkr 1/28/13 6:42 pm

1) Run Like an Antelope
2) Bathtub Gin
3) Down with Disease
4) Chalkdust Torture
5) Fee
6) Divided Sky
7) Reba
8) Weekapaug Groove
9) Runaway Jim
10) You Enjoy Myself

Score: 0

me_no_are_no_nice_guy 1/28/13 6:47 pm

@Fikus said:

Songs I could see every show.

That's good enough for me....

1. YEM
2. Antelope
3. Mike's Song
4. Fluffhead
5. Moma Dance
6. Camel Walk
7. Harry Hood
8. Makisupa Policeman
9. David Bowie
10. Split Open and Melt

Score: 0