Try our mobile site, m.phish.net!

Phish.net: a Project of the Mockingbird Foundation




Back to Forum Back to Forum Oldest First Oldest First Newest First Newest First

Have you given up on CD's yet?

12Next →View All

me_no_are_no_nice_guy Permalink
me_no_are_no_nice_guy I'm CD free. The player in my car doesn't work, and I have no need to get it fixed. I'm all MP3/Spotify/Vinyl now. I was at my friend's place the other day and he has about 4000 cd's. He was playing me some different stuff and I realized how antiquated CD's are to me now-a-days. Anyone else CD free, or considering it?
Score: 2

WGphan92 Permalink
WGphan92 Only time I use CDs is burning them for the car. No aux input in my car so its either cd or radio and I rarely listen to the radio.
Score: 4

nematode Permalink
nematode I stick to cassette/mp3/vinyl myself, CDs have no place in my life.
Score: 1

me_no_are_no_nice_guy Permalink
me_no_are_no_nice_guy @nematode said:
I stick to cassette/mp3/vinyl myself, CDs have no place in my life.
cassettes? interesting. I have a few cassettes I play since my car has a cassette player. Recently picked up the best of Kenny Rogers cassette for 50 cents to check out.
Score: 1

nematode Permalink
nematode Only reason I still use cassettes is the car I have has a player and we sometimes record music on an old ass 8-track recorder.
Score: 1

TheEmperorJoker Permalink
TheEmperorJoker CDS for the car. I have a sync in my car that hooks up with my ipod but it's just too difficult to mess with while driving.
Score: 1

maplesteam Permalink
Im not in the sense that a lot of the technology I use still have a cd player. Im thinking of my computer, my dvd player (which I used to play cds over when we were hanging out in the living room and I didnt have any other sound system). But I listen to about 70 percent of my music on grooveshark and 30 percent at work (a friend's itunes) so ya f*** cds.
Score: 1

lefty Permalink
lefty What are CDs? harddrive connected to your car audio via usb or at home get tbs of music on internal harddrives in your computer pushed through amps and fatty speaks or STFU...!
Score: 1

me_no_are_no_nice_guy Permalink
me_no_are_no_nice_guy @lefty said:
What are CDs? harddrive connected to your car audio via usb or at home get tbs of music on internal harddrives in your computer pushed through amps and fatty speaks or STFU...!

Image
Score: 5

jaylimmo Permalink
Oddly enough, before yesterday the answer would have been yes. BUT....

I had a spare $10 iTunes gift card laying around. Lo and behold, the new album by The Joy Formidable is $9.99 on iTunes. I was especially jazzed because it was mixed by Andy Wallace, who mixed three of my favorite records ever. The notes on the download page say it was "mastered for iTunes." Hmm.

So it ended up on my iPod, and I listened to a few songs from The Big Roar before listening to the new album. Put on the new album. It sounded flat compared to the first album, and the drums were less prominent.

Since I didn't pay for the album in the first place, I'm going to buy the CD and hope that it sounds better. If so, I'll rip 320k mp3s. If not, I won't bother. Either way I'm supporting an amazing band that I'm happy to throw money at.

But in general: yeah, most of my CDs live in the garage.
Score: 0

TheArgus Permalink
TheArgus I spend about an hour and a half in my car on days where I have school and work (most days.... ;) ) So I rely pretty heavily on CDs. I do have an auxiliary jack to hook my phone or an ipod or something into my cars stereo, but I don't wanna be tempted to pull my phone out to change songs when I can just hit a button on my steering wheel and change the song or the disc using a CD.

At home, I prefer vinyl or digital, but I still use CD's frequently. Mainly because the laptop where the majority of my music (well not majority, but easily accesiable) has a screen which no longer works and is currently stuck on a desk in my room hooked into an external monitor.

So burning a disc to play in the living room has become a common ritual on drunk nights when I gotta hear some specific set or a song, which leads to filling out the discs with other random songs that I can think of off the top of my head, which leads to some rather eclectic CDs which usually end up in my car for future use.

AAAAAnd my post has gone full circle.
Score: 1

spaced Permalink
spaced @jaylimmo said:
"mastered for iTunes."
lol
Score: 3

spaced Permalink
spaced Oh, to answer the question, I have exactly one functioning CD player now that the one in my car stopped working, so I basically never use them except when I'm doing something in the kitchen. If I'm on my computer and want to listen to one of them, half the time I'm too lazy to go look for it and just illegally download the FLACs instead.
Score: 1

bostonron Permalink
bostonron I had my lifetime of CDs stolen in '09 (all except my Phish. Funny how that works). Probably close to 2000 CDs. There was no way I was recoup all that so I decided it was time to go digital. I don't miss it at all. I have way more music now then I ever did. It was such a pain in the ass when I moved. The one thing I do miss is the aesthetics. I had two huge bookcases full of my CDs and it was cool as shit to see that. While I was somewhat forced to go digital I am much happier with the transition.
Score: 1

jaylimmo Permalink
yeah, i know.

"mastered for 8-track"

"mastered for wax cylinder."
Score: 1

Drgordy Permalink
Drgordy Ill buy used CDs sometimes rather than a digital download, but they get burned to the computer and then end up in a box afterwards. With an aux port for the iPod in the car there isn't much use for them.
Score: 1

MomentsandSeconds Permalink
MomentsandSeconds Like 5 years ago. Haven't used one in years.
Score: 1

weekapaug19 Permalink
yes, a lot, but my mp3 player broke so I'm back to cd's full time now. Anybody have an old one they don't use anymore?
Score: 0

Shukky Permalink
I am 90% CD free and have been since last summer. My wife's car is the only one not but we are not in there all that often.

Score: 0

JayDubya Permalink
JayDubya I'm close to being "CD Free" but I still listen to them in my truck. I don't have an Aux input there. I have one of those fm ipod connectors but it sucks.

I still have all of my cds though. I've got hundreds of SHN and FLAC discs from when I used to snail mail trade them before FTP took off.
Score: 0

scottygelbs Permalink
scottygelbs I'm in between. Whats the best way to convert preexisting CD's to digital? Ext. harddrive?
Score: 0

mattk97 Permalink
mattk97 It seems like I am the only one who enjoys buying CDs still! I enjoy going to the record store and spending time looking through the racks to find some cheap ones to rip to my computer. However after the first listen through, I usually don't listen to the CD, seems like they are merely there for aesthetics. I am also an avid vinyl buyer and listener
Score: 0

Angler Permalink
Angler I buy CDs and rip them to my PC so that I can put them on my iPod. CDs then go in my cabinet. I like the initial tactile experience of handling the CD, reading the liner notes, looking at photos, etc. I also like having an archival copy of music that is really important to me in case my computer crashes and I lose everything. I have an external hard drive to back music files up on, but that could crash, too. I also have an extensive collection of vinyl. I grew up with records, and the physical artifact is part of the enjoyment of music for me. I've bought a bunch of the Grateful Dead box sets like the Winterland 73 and Winterland 77, Dave's Picks, etc., and I love reading the extensive liner notes, looking at photos, etc. while I put them on my computer. Even after I've loaded them on my PC/iPod, I'll get them out and listen to them on the CD when I'm sitting around listening to music at home. Not only does it sound better, but it is a much more engaging listening experience to handle the physical object, load it in the player, etc. This is even more true of listening to records.

I have a buddy who buys CDs, puts them on his PC/iPod and then sells them on Amazon or Ebay and has no physical collection. He has a lot of this on his PC at work. Over Christmas break, the IT guys wiped everything out on his computer, and he lost all of his music.
Score: 3

spencur6 Permalink
spencur6 I don't use them on a regular basis. They're mostly for the car or doing work around the house with the old man. do I still buy them? Hell yeah. I love having physical copies of music. Liner notes and all. I prefer to have discs. Not that they're used a lot but i do rip them and keep them. I like having music in tangible form.
Score: 0

AugustWest2001 Permalink
AugustWest2001 Mini discs have come and gone but the good old compact disc still has life as a relevant product.
Score: 0

RoverPhish Permalink
I find I usually buy CDs for albums that i've previously really liked via MP3. I probably buy 3 or so CDs a year, tops. Obviously, nothing like I used to. I will then rip them at 320 into iTunes and EAC the WAV files for archiving if needed. Then I'll put the CDs in the rotation on my CD player. I'm pretty much over the ipod/iphone docking stereos or cable hookups. I'd rather save money for a high end system that can play high quality digital music. Otherwise, i'll stick with the CDs while at home.
Score: 0

mjrphishhead Permalink
mjrphishhead I'm with @Angler here, I will buy a CD unless I absolutely cannot find one anywhere near me. Having the liner notes and all the packaging is big for me plus I have it backed up.
Score: 0

julesmac Permalink
julesmac um, CDs are digital...lossless digital...

mp3 = lossy digital
Score: 3

ledzepmaster Permalink
ledzepmaster CD's for car's 6 CD changer, mp3's for ipod traveling on train and longer drives.
Score: 0

chris_22 Permalink
chris_22 I still buy CDs on the reg. But also purchase albums via the net as well. I like having something physical. Plus some of the booklets are pretty cool with the CDs.
Score: 1

RR1994 Permalink
@WGphan92 said:
Only time I use CDs is burning them for the car. No aux input in my car so its either cd or radio and I rarely listen to the radio.
Same here. I don't use CD's in the house, but when I'm cruising in my car it is either CD's or bust.
Score: 0

jayman Permalink
I just started getting into FLAC/lossless audio files, so I guess I prefer the CD quality, but unless I'm in my car that only has a CD player, i'm 100% digital.
Score: 0

AugustWest2001 Permalink
AugustWest2001 Flac is just as digitally pure as a cd, just compressed - right?
Score: 0

spaced Permalink
spaced @AugustWest2001 said:
Flac is just as digitally pure as a cd, just compressed - right?
Yup, no difference whatsoever. Technically, if it was ripped from a CD, you have to make sure that it was done accurately with a program like Exact Audio Copy (EAC), but these days, most people who care enough to use FLAC are probably going to use EAC anyway, so it's not really a big deal.
Score: 0

MySoula Permalink
MySoula No, I haven't given up.

They are reminders, just as much as the music. I still have phish shows my brother gave me years ago in college (as a xmas gift) and enjoy throwing them in. Still have binders in my car (yes I have an iPod that plugs into my car). I just still enjoy CDs and would need a month of free time to upload them all onto my computer.

I also play a decent amount of vinyl when I have time and XM as background music at home.

It's just so easy to scroll over or skip putting a CD on your computer you rarely listen to...I find myself listening to more of a variety of music when I flip thru some CDs. Listened to a mixed CD this morning.
Score: 1

joonze Permalink
joonze its been about 2 years of being cd free as in physically placing one in a player to listen to music...all my music is stored as flac (majority) and some mp3 (music given to me from phish ticket stubs, or my co-worker that has anything and everything i can think of)

I really miss my 8-Tracks though....
Score: 0

Capricornio Permalink
Capricornio I still buy CDs for albums that are not available on vinyl. I probably bought less than 5 CDs last year.
Score: 0

MySoula Permalink
MySoula I should add I don't really buys CDs outside of shows that have a booth for the artist(s).
Score: 0

tmwsiy Phish.net Staff Permalink
tmwsiy Haven't listened to a CD in five years or so. Likewise, don't own a DVD player anymore either.
Streaming or bust. A have several TB's of music backed up both locally and in the cloud and stream/DL/cache to my phone, laptop or wherever I am with Subsonic. Movies via Boxee. Same with books I guess- it is on the Kindle or I don't read it.
Score: 0

themefromthepossum Permalink
we were at my grandma's house on christmas eve, for dinner; she has an old-school portable CD player/boombox. we were going through a pile of christmas music cd's and it was my turn to change the CD. it took me a minute to 'remember' how to use the dam thing
Score: 0

Capricornio Permalink
Capricornio @tmwsiy said:
Haven't listened to a CD in five years or so. Likewise, don't own a DVD player anymore either.
Streaming or bust. A have several TB's of music backed up both locally and in the cloud and stream/DL/cache to my phone, laptop or wherever I am with Subsonic. Movies via Boxee. Same with books I guess- it is on the Kindle or I don't read it.
How do you like Subsonic? I was recently looking into this. Do you stream from your own computer or did you purchase one of their server packages? Does it work well?
Score: 0

tmwsiy Phish.net Staff Permalink
tmwsiy @Capricornio said:


How do you like Subsonic? I was recently looking into this. Do you stream from your own computer or did you purchase one of their server packages? Does it work well?
Nothing to lose! It is free. If you want your own domain name, you need to make a one-time donation. Otherwise can just use an IP address.

PM me and I'll set you up on my server for a couple of days to check it out. No need to buy a server package if you have half decent bandwidth at home. My computer is always on and I have FiOS so there is no need in my case.

Subsonic also does video which is pretty sweet. And you can cache any of your folders for offline use.

Score: 0

dsanbensoff Permalink
dsanbensoff It is sad to think that people use mp3 as a replacement for a CD.
Score: 1

ledzepmaster Permalink
ledzepmaster @dsanbensoff said:
It is sad to think that people use mp3 as a replacement for a CD.
Only if their mp3 bit rate is under 256 kbps.

I've tested ALAC vs an 320 kbps mp3 and the difference is hardly noticeable; even with proper headphones.
Score: 0

cactoid Permalink
cactoid MP3 CDs man, you can put like 5 albums on one disc.

All you people talking about how much better FLAC sounds vs a V0 MP3 are just friggin jizzing into the wind
Score: 1

dscott Permalink
Ditch the CDs?? Never!!!
Score: 0

BigPimpinNYC Permalink
I have a handful for sentamental reason but my CD collection was given to my nephew.

back-up HD for the win!
Score: 0

AnalogKid Permalink
AnalogKid I'm partial towards vinyl, but I got pretty heavily invested in CDs back in the early 80's, and I've got a couple of thousand, so I'm still buying them. My g/f subscribed me to Dave's Picks, so I'm definitely not done with the format. As digital recording technology continues to catch up with where analog was, the potential of the format is still expanding. I'd like to believe that the turn towards high resolution digital files is going to render them obsolete, but when people are happy with a 128kbps MP3, I don't see this happening.

I'm actually looking to buy the Oppo BDP 105 Universal BluRay Player, an audiophile grade component that plays any audio or video format available. It also has a high-end DAC built into it along with wireless and LAN inputs so you can use it to stream your ripped audio files (which I also have). It's an all-in-one music server for your digital entertainment needs.
Score: 0

12Next →View All

You must be logged in to leave a comment!

Username

Password

Register | Forgot Password


Back to Forum Back to Forum Oldest First Oldest First Newest First Newest First
Login Register