Back to Forum
Oldest First
Newest First
The two easy ones for me, are DCU 1 Boogie on in 2012, and SPAC 2012 SplOAM.Agreed? Any other versions of songs that you would think the general consensus would be "This is the best version of this song in 3.0, hands down!"?
Score: 2
Runaway Jim 8/31/12 is one. Also, I think the 8/2/09 Boogie On is in the conversation with 6/7/12.
Score: 2
Chalkdust from Dicks and Runaway Jim from Dicks are the two most obvious best of 3.0's
Would also put Halleys from Bethel in there.
Would also put Halleys from Bethel in there.
Score: 2
12/28/12 Wolfmans Brother
Score: 12
@FeelingIForgot said:
12/28/12 Wolfmans Brother12.28.12 Tweezer as well
Score: 7
@itsice88 said: @FeelingIForgot said:12/28/12 Wolfmans Brother12.28.12 Tweezer as well
Ys and yes! Especialllllly for Wolfmans
Score: 2
Yeah, the 12/28/12 tweezer and wolfmans are the winners IMO. Dcu boogie has some competition. Check the aforementioned red rocks version and also look into telluride. As for melt, look into Cincy '09, Hershey '10, and uttica. I like those better than spac. As for my list of "hands down best of 3.0:Halley's Comet- bethel
Wilson and mound- sb9
Crosseyed- bgca n3
Rock and roll- gorge '11
Score: 3
Was the best Carini hands down in 3.0, 12/30/12?
Score: 1
Is the best YEM hands down 12/4/09?
Score: 0
Yes and no
Score: 1
@WookiePhart said: Chalkdust from Dicks and Runaway Jim from Dicks are the two most obvious best of 3.0'sthere was a chalkdust from 09 or 10 in camden that was pretty great too...
Would also put Halleys from Bethel in there.
Score: 1
Blossom Possum from '11Bethel Waves soundcheck (best ever?)
Limb By Limb St. Louis '12
Twist Cincy '12 (this last one is debatable)
Score: 4
@donatelloI would agree w/ all of yours. Also a big yes on that waves being my all time favorite.
Score: 1
I would put the Sand from Dicks this year up against any Sand, from any era.
Score: 5
I think that some of these don't get the credit they deserve but here goes:Albany '09 Seven Below > Ghost
Camden '10 2001
Woosta '10 Hood
Bethel '11 KDF
MPP '11 Makisupa
Portsmouth '11 Sand
SBIX '11 Destiny Unbound
Long Beach '12 Rock & Roll > Ghost
BGCA '12 Crosseyed & Painless
Dick's '12 Light
MSG '12 DWD
Score: 4
Also how can we forget the Mound from 7/3/11. 
Score: 4
7/1/12 Fee
Score: 2
@MiguelSanchez : Now that I think about it, that LxL might also qualify as "best ever." You were at that one, right?@ivy_light : some great picks there! I know it's been hotly debated lately, but I have to give the edge to the Disease from Clarkston '11.
Score: 1
Best secret jam... super
I think tweezers, ghosts, twists, etc are more debatable than some ppl are thinking
I think tweezers, ghosts, twists, etc are more debatable than some ppl are thinking
Score: 1
Roses 6/8/12
Score: 1
Super all*
Score: 0
Superball*
Score: 0
Berkley Cities
Score: 1
Twist is definitely 6/22/12
Score: 0
I've been digging Set II of 6/29/12 lately. DWD> Sand is tasty.
Score: 0
@Babyrattlesnakes said: @MiguelSanchez : Now that I think about it, that LxL might also qualify as "best ever." You were at that one, right?no, i was not at that one, much to my regret. It is one of my favorite shows from last year. the funny thing is, i was at the other 2 shows with the limb by limbs that i think would round out a top 3 versions, cincy '99 and msg '98.
@ivy_light : some great picks there! I know it's been hotly debated lately, but I have to give the edge to the Disease from Clarkston '11.
Score: 1
Best Carini is still 6/7/12. Not 12/30/12 or 8/31/12.
Score: 3
@Superballin said: Best Carini is still 6/7/12. Not 12/30/12 or 8/31/12.i love the 6/7 version. the pairing with taste was quite snazzy too, but i greatly prefer 12/30.
Score: 2
bathtub - gorge 09
gbott - miami 09
birdwatcher - deer creek 12
mcgrupp - deer creek 12
i agree with the blossom possum, and the msg tweezer and wolfman's as well.
and the one two punch of the all of these dreams> maze on the final night of hampton is hard to ignore. think about it!
gbott - miami 09
birdwatcher - deer creek 12
mcgrupp - deer creek 12
i agree with the blossom possum, and the msg tweezer and wolfman's as well.
and the one two punch of the all of these dreams> maze on the final night of hampton is hard to ignore. think about it!
Score: 0
@ivy_light that Seven Below> Ghost from Albany 09 is definitely some hot shit. It's almost 45 minutes of pure bliss jamming. I've been listening to this one a lot lately
Score: 1
@mathemagician said:
I've been digging Set II of 6/29/12 lately. DWD> Sand is tasty.you can really hear the joey arkenstat influence in mike's playing during that sand. i still thoroughly enjoy it to this day.
Score: 1
SOAM from Spac is the tits!!!! Complete mind F***!
Score: 2
split tie between the UIC and Dicks Undermind. Dicks Sand
AC BIlly Breathes, I mention this one all the time
Score: 2
@Bikepgh said: bathtub - gorge 09i don't really know how to qualify "best birdwatcher." the sample size is pretty small too. i definitely agree with the bathtub and gbott calls. i'm not overly impressed with fest 8, but the acoustic mcgrupp was pretty cool. i still agree with the deer creek call. in fact, i believe it's the best version in 12+ years, but the uniqueness of the acoustic version is worth mentioning.
gbott - miami 09
birdwatcher - deer creek 12
mcgrupp - deer creek 12
Score: 0
@MiguelSanchez said: 
@Bikepgh said:nobody mentioned a sample size regulationbathtub - gorge 09i don't really know how to qualify "best birdwatcher." the sample size is pretty small too. i definitely agree with the bathtub and gbott calls. i'm not overly impressed with fest 8, but the acoustic mcgrupp was pretty cool. i still agree with the deer creek call. in fact, i believe it's the best version in 12+ years, but the uniqueness of the acoustic version is worth mentioning.
gbott - miami 09
birdwatcher - deer creek 12
mcgrupp - deer creek 12
Score: 2
^true
Score: 0
Score: 1
8/15/12 best Kill Devil Falls.
Score: 1
Who has my best Divided Sky and Slave? I will toss the versions from 12/30/12 on the table.
Score: 0
@Jimmymac03 said: Who has my best Divided Sky and Slave? I will toss the versions from 12/30/12 on the table.Definitely the best 3.0 Slave I've heard...I can't get enough of that version. The Divided Sky is great too. Hell I even loved Back on the Train from that show.
Score: 1
You could argue the 12.28.12 Tweezer but its hard to decide between that one and Dicks 2011 Tweezer
Score: 3
Heavy things - bader 2012.6.15Curtain with - Camden 2011.6.10
Cities - Greek '10
Score: 2
@Jimmymac03 said:
8/15/12 best Kill Devil Falls.I would argue 7.8.12 SPAC
Score: 2
@TwiceBitten said: @Jimmymac03 said:D-Sky is 6/7/11 or 12/30/12. Slave goes to 12/30 or 9/2/11. Hood-9/4/11.Who has my best Divided Sky and Slave? I will toss the versions from 12/30/12 on the table.Definitely the best 3.0 Slave I've heard...I can't get enough of that version. The Divided Sky is great too. Hell I even loved Back on the Train from that show.
Score: 2
@itsice88 said: @Jimmymac03 said:And I would argue the swingin' 5/27/11 version.8/15/12 best Kill Devil Falls.I would argue 7.8.12 SPAC
Score: 0
Nobody has mentioned the Quinn The Eskimo from Superball. That one could be the "best ever", that I've heard anyway.
Score: 1
@conradjohansen said: @TwiceBitten said:check out the creek '10 slave. it is a whopper.@Jimmymac03 said:D-Sky is 6/7/11 or 12/30/12. Slave goes to 12/30 or 9/2/11. Hood-9/4/11.Who has my best Divided Sky and Slave? I will toss the versions from 12/30/12 on the table.Definitely the best 3.0 Slave I've heard...I can't get enough of that version. The Divided Sky is great too. Hell I even loved Back on the Train from that show.
Score: 4
How about Reba? SuperBall might be the most "unique," but otherwise? Cincy '11 is a pretty tasty version, but I feel like I'm overlooking something...
Score: 0
UIC alumni> LTJP> alumni
Score: 1
@Babyrattlesnakes said: Blossom Possum from '11
Bethel Waves soundcheck (best ever?)
Limb By Limb St. Louis '12
Twist Cincy '12 (this last one is debatable)
Nice call on the Limb by Limb
Score: 0
You must be logged in to leave a comment!